All posts by Emerson Green

CA42 Argument From Personal Experience



One of the weakest and most common arguments encountered, the argument from personal experience stands out as a conspicuous reminder of the shortcomings of religious apologetics in general and religious epistemology in particular. 
I recorded parts of this when I was a little under the weather so I apologize for the intermittent frog in my throat.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

. . . . .

Epistemology [Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy]
Epistemology of Religion [Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy]
Reformed Epistemology [Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy]

CA41 Argument From Biblical Confusion



The existence of Biblical, Koranic, or Talmudic confusion is not easy to square with an omni-god who inspired, dictated, or otherwise controlled the contents of a holy book. The Bible is long, vague, contradictory, ambiguous, and has no obvious message. There are about as many interpretations of the Bible as there are readers of the Bible, but why should this be the case? Wouldn’t god want to make her message as clear as possible, especially since these issues are literally life and death? If god is omniscient and omnipotent, she would know exactly how to make her message impossible to misunderstand, leaving no room for misinterpretation or confusion. In her omniscience, she would see all the strife, bloodshed, and damnation that would result from her lack of clarity; if she was omni-benevolent, she would want to avoid this and make her message clear. How is it possible that two sincere believers, approaching god’s word in good faith, can come away with clashing interpretations of god’s message that leaves one of them destined to burn for all eternity?

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

. . .

The argument from biblical confusion against Christianity — Jonathan Garner [Philosophy of Religion blog]


CA40 Speaking in Tongues / Glossolalia



Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

. . .

Glossolalia [Wiki]

Glossolalia [Rational Wiki]

Heather Kavan — Linguistics of Glossolalia [PDF]

William Samarin — Linguistics of Glossolalia [Amazon]

Andrew Newberg — Glossolalia Neuroimaging Study [PDF]

Wired — Glossolalia Neuroimaging Study [Wired]

Glossolalia – OWN [YouTube]

Dan Barker – Tongue Speaking [YouTube]

Anti-Glossolalia Christian Writer [GotQuestions]

Patheos — Non-Christian Glossolalia [Patheos]

Bart Ehrman — Tongue Speaking and Snake Handling in Mark [EhrmanBlog]

Prank Calling Joel Osteen’s Prayer Line [YouTube]

. . .

[Clips of glossolalia]

Crazy hat lady

Totally normal

nothing to see here

Jesus Camp — excerpt

ABC segment


CA39 The Story of God — Conversation with Chris Matheson



Chris Matheson is a screenwriter and author whose credits include Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure, Rapture-palooza, The Story of God, and The Trouble with God.

You can buy The Story of God here and The Trouble with God here [Amazon] 

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

“The religion of one age is the literary entertainment of the next.” — Ralph Waldo Emerson


CA38 The Evil God Challenge



Stephen Law’s Evil God presents a challenge to theists: Explain why the hypothesis that there exists an omnipotent, omniscient, and omni-benevolent god should be considered significantly more reasonable than an omnipotent, omniscient, and omni-malevolent god. Many of the most popular arguments for god’s existence (first cause, intelligent design, fine-tuning) don’t give us any indication of god’s moral orientation. So is there any way to render Good God significantly more reasonable to believe in than Evil God?

Sorry again about the cold if it hurt the quality.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

The Evil God Challenge — Stephen Law [Cambridge University Press]

Stephen Law — Evil God Challenge [The Panpsycast]

Evil God Challenge — CFI UK [YouTube]


CA37 The God of Jordan Peterson, Pt. II



We discuss the utility of fiction, the future of Christianity, and psychonautic Shaman biologists.

I’m still getting over a cold, hopefully it didn’t come through that much.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

Jordan Peterson on DNA, psychedelics, ancient humans [YouTube]

Rationality Rules — Atheists Are Not Murderers [YouTube]

Jordan Peterson — Waking Up [YouTube]

Matt Dillahunty / Jordan Peterson Debate [YouTube]

Game Theory — Playlist [YouTube]

Robert Wright — “Non-zero-sumness” [YouTube]

F*ck 12 — Chapo Trap House [YouTube]


CA36 The God of Jordan Peterson, Pt. I



Jordan Peterson is an unusual Christian apologist. Beyond a few of the standard apologetic tropes he spouts (we need god to be moral, atheists aren’t really atheists, Judeo-Christian values created Western civilization, atheism leads to communism), he defends god by adopting a pragmatic conception of truth that allows him to circumvent traditional arguments surrounding god’s existence. He claims to be a Christian, but his Christianity is not one most Christians would recognize. And yet, many have tried to claim him as their own. We explore Peterson’s notion of Jesus, god, and truth, and touch on his belief that atheism is corrosive to civilization and to morality itself.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

Rationality Rules — Peterson’s Truth [YouTube]

Rationality Rules — JP Is Not A Christian [YouTube]

Matt Dillahunty / Jordan Peterson Debate [YouTube]

Bret Weinstein on Metaphorical Truth [YouTube]

Jordan Peterson on Truth — Transliminal Interview [YouTube]

Jordan Peterson on Truth — Waking Up [YouTube]

Jordan Peterson — Gawd [YouTube]


CA35 The Gruesome History of Christian Torture



Christianity has a long and romantic relationship with torture. The primary symbol of the religion is a torture device, God’s chosen method of providing salvation was a grisly act of public torture, and hell has been an object of fascination for Christian artists, writers, and church fathers since the beginning. As the religious scholar Karen King puts it, there are “torturous narratives at Christianity’s foundations.” Obsession with torture, though not unique to Christianity by any means, has always been in Christianity’s DNA. We also discuss the witch craze, the theologically-induced mass hysteria that led to gruesome acts against “witches” for centuries.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

Christopher Hitchens [YouTube]

Skeptical Examination of Torture [YouTube]

The Moral Arc – Michael Shermer [Amazon]

Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds – Charles MacKay [Amazon]

The End of Faith – Sam Harris [Amazon]

Triumph of Christianity – Bart Ehrman [Amazon]


CA34 Women v. Religion — Conversation with Karen Garst



Author Karen Garst joins me to discuss a range of topics, including the high level of religiosity among women, the influence of mythology, abortion, and her upcoming debate at Mythcon. She has recently released a book entitled Women v. Religion: The Case Against Faith and for Freedom, which is the primary subject of our conversation today.

Women v. Religion [Amazon] 

If you’d like to hear Karen speak at Mythcon, you can buy tickets here.

Faithless Feminist Blog

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA33 Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism (EAAN)



The discovery of evolution by natural selection arguably did more to reinforce naturalism than any other single discovery in science. However, not everyone agrees that Darwinian evolution was a blow against god. In fact, Alvin Plantinga, a Christian apologist, thinks that you can’t believe both in Darwinism and naturalism simultaneously — they’re incompatible. We discuss his famous argument and also wonder why god is such an incompetent engineer.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism [wiki]

Alvin Plantinga on EAAN [YouTube]

Warrant and Proper Function – Alvin Plantinga (Excerpt) [Google Books]

rd23 Plantinga Schmantinga [Reasonable Doubts Podcast]

Massimo Pigliucci on EAAN [Rationally Speaking Blog]

List of Cognitive Biases [wiki]

A Critique of Plantinga’s Probabilities in EAAN [PDF]

(I didn’t cover this part of the argument, but I would’ve pointed out that in Plantinga’s Bayesian reasoning, he sets his priors absurdly low.)

Richard Dawkins on Evolution [YouTube]


CA32 Does Christianity Make Sense? — Conversation with Evan Davids



Author Evan Davids joins me to discuss why there is something rather than nothing, evolution, biblical literalism, whether Evan is really an atheist, the Fall, hell, abortion, and other topics.

Christianity No Longer Makes Sense – Evan Davids [Amazon]

EvanDavids.com

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA31 The Ethics of Abortion



Can abortion be morally justified? We know that Christians generally think it’s abhorrent. But once we’ve left religion behind, how should we draw a conclusion about such a contentious moral issue? Independent moral reasoning is something atheists, naturalists, and skeptics can’t avoid, so we shouldn’t shy away from intra-group discussion about one of the most important moral issues of our time.

Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook

Support on Patreon

Read transcripts of the podcast and discuss other issues at the Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Listen to Magic Tricks by Whalers

2014 Abortion Data [cdc.gov]

Fetal Pain: A Systematic, Multidisciplinary Review of the Evidence [Journal of the American Medical Association]

Can Fetuses Feel Pain? [British Medical Journal]

Utilitarianism [Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy]

The Impact of Legalized Abortion on Crime — Donohue-Levitt Hypothesis [PDF – Quarterly Journal of Economics]

Freakonomics — Abortion and Crime [Freakonomics]

The Trolley Problem — Massimo Pigliucci [YouTube]

“But the peculiar evil of silencing the expression of an opinion is, that it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the opportunity of exchanging error for truth: if wrong, they lose, what is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier impression of truth, produced by its collision with error.” — J.S. Mill


CA30 Western Values Are Based on Judeo-Christian Values



Is western civilization a product of Judeo-Christian values? Apologists assert that Judeo-Christian values influenced the thinkers of the Renaissance and the Enlightenment so greatly as to deserve credit as the foundation of western values. So even if Judeo-Christian beliefs are entirely untrue, could the mythology could be a useful fiction that created the west as we know it?

CA Facebook

CA Patreon

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Rationality Rules – Western Civilization is Based on Judeo-Christian Values [YouTube]

Nonstampcollector – Ten Commandments [YouTube]

The Basis of Western Civilization – Jordan Peterson [YouTube]

Western Civilization – Ben Shapiro [YouTube]

Richard Dawkins – Militant Atheism [YouTube]

Ben Shaprio – Ten Commandments [YouTube]

Sam Harris – Ten Commandments [YouTube]

Hitchens on Morality [YouTube]

Stephen Fry on Ten Commandments [YouTube]

Yaron Brook on Judeo-Christian Values [YouTube]

Sam Harris vs. Ben Shapiro [YouTube]

Ben Shapiro vs. Sam Harris — TMM [YouTube]

TMM on Ben Shapiro [YouTube]

Bible Verses on Obeying Governments [KnowingJesus]

The Myth of the Jewish Origins of the Renaissance [PDF]

Bertrand Russell — Why I Am Not a Christian [Amazon]


CA29 Science vs. The Soul



Are we just electrified meat or is there a ghost in the machine? Believers claim that naturalism cannot account for the phenomenal properties of consciousness and tend to hold the position that the mind is more than the biological activity of the brain. We examine the conventional idea of the soul and how it conflicts with science.

CA Patreon

CA Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe

Steven Novella’s Excellent Blog [NeurologicaBlog]

The Neuroscience of Consciousness — Anil Seth [YouTube]

Consciousness – Anil Seth and Sam Harris [YouTube]

Crash Course Philosophy – Philosophy of Mind [YouTube]

Steven Novella and Sean Carroll – Intelligence Squared [IQ^2]

Causation and Emergence – Sean Carroll [PreposterousUniverse]

Sean Carroll – Zombies and the Hard Problem [Nautilus]

Substance Dualism – QualiaSoup [YouTube]

Richard Feynman – Science [YouTube]

The Interaction Problem – TMM [YouTube]

Mind-Brain Interaction and the Violation of Physical Laws – DL Wilson [PDF]


CA28 State Atheism



Christian apologists, citing a few twentieth-century regimes, often try to conflate atheism and authoritarianism. They ignore the fact that most atheists are secularists and don’t advocate for any form of state atheism. They also ignore the fact that the policies of the atheist states they cite, most frequently North Korea and the Soviet Union, were transparently motivated by a totalitarian desire to control their populations. We discuss secularism, freedom of belief, religious toleration, Christian communism, and separation of church and state.

Part two of the consciousness series is taking a little longer than expected, so I thought I’d continue the atheism and the 20th-century series back from episodes eight and nine.

CA Patreon

CA Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Christopher Hitchens on Stalin [YouTube]

Church-State Separation — Christopher Hitchens [YouTube]

Michael Shermer — Intelligence Squared U.S. [YouTube]

The Gulag Archipelago — Alekandr Solzhenitsyn [Amazon]


CA27 Argument from Consciousness



Can consciousness only be explained on a theistic worldview? Christians often appeal to the phenomenon of consciousness and argue that it’s unlikely or impossible on naturalism. We discuss substance dualism, the hard problem of consciousness, identity, intentionality, and the unclear role the material realm plays in theism.

CA Facebook

CA Patreon

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Counter Apologetics Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Christianity No Longer Makes Sense — Evan Davids [Amazon]

Evan Davids’ Official Website

The Neuroscience of Consciousness — Anil Seth [YouTube]

Consciousness – Anil Seth and Sam Harris [YouTube]

Thomas Nagel – What is it like to be a bat? [PDF]

Sean Carroll – Zombies and the Hard Problem [Nautilus]

Crash Course Philosophy – Philosophy of Mind [YouTube]

Rationality Rules – Argument From Consciousness [YouTube]

William Lane Craig on the Soul [YouTube]

Consciousness – Steven Pinker [YouTube]


CA26 The Spread of Christianity



A forbidden religion, originally composed of only a few devoted followers, eventually swept the western world. Believers think that the rise of Christianity was so unusual to suggest it was miraculous, and they argue that the stunning growth and eventual size of their religion is evidence that God really is on their side. We explore the historical causes behind the spread of Christianity and try not to sound condescending as we explain that the popularity of a belief isn’t evidence.

CA Patreon

Follow me on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

The Triumph of Christianity: How a Forbidden Religion Swept the World — Bart Ehrman [Amazon]

Bart Ehrman Interview [NPR]

Christopher Hitchens [YouTube]

2015 Religious Demographics [Pew]

How Many Anatomically Modern Humans Have Lived on Earth? [PRB]

Your Logical Fallacy Is…


CA25 Who Would Die for a Lie?



Christians claim that the majority of the disciples were martyred for their belief in the resurrection. They were tortured and killed in horrible ways, supposedly for their beliefs. And who would go through that for a lie?

CA Patreon

Follow me on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Tracie Harris — Why Martyrs? [Atheist Experience Blog]

Were the Disciples Martyred? [EhrmanBlog]

Easter Reflection [EhrmanBlog]

Paul’s Execution [MappingTheMartyrs]

Stephen’s Martyr Legend [Acts 6-7]


The Trilemma: Lunatic, Liar, or Lord? — Easter Bonus



Liar, lunatic, or lord? C.S. Lewis says we have to make our choice. Jesus must have been one of these three things, and there are definitely no other options. We also discuss the historical Jesus and clarify a detail from last week’s Easter episode regarding the women’s discovery of the empty tomb.

I hope none of you have to suffer through church today! If you do, try to steal some money out of the plate (don’t get caught).

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Eviction by Whalers

“If Jesus Never Called Himself God, How Did He Become One?” [YouTube]

How Jesus Became God — Bart Ehrman [Amazon]

Misquoting Jesus — Bart Ehrman [Amazon]

Trilemma – Matt Dillahunty [YouTube]

Josh McDowell on the Trilemma [YouTube]

C.S. Lewis — Mere Christianity (audio excerpt) [YouTube]

The Ending of Mark [wiki]


CA24 Easter — The Resurrection of Jesus



Today, we discuss the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus, the evidence for the Gospel stories, and what it’s all supposed to mean.

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Oldest Manuscript of 1 Corinthians 15:6 [Wiki]

The Ending of Mark [wiki]

Bart Ehrman on Gospel Eyewitnesses [EhrmanBlog]

Bart Ehrman on the Resurrection [YouTube]

How Jesus Became God — Bart Ehrman [Amazon]

TMM on the Resurrection [YouTube]

Matt Dillahunty on God’s Mysterious Ineptitude [YouTube]

Sam Harris on Jesus’ Miracles [YouTube]

Christopher Hitchens on Vicarious Redemption [YouTube]

Dan Barker on the “Good News” [YouTube]


CA23 The New Testament is Better



Once we get past the bloody and bizarre Old Testament, it’s all “Love thy neighbor” and “Help the poor” from there, isn’t it? We’re expected to accept that Jesus was a wise moral teacher and that the New Testament is a valuable document of morals, even if we aren’t believers ourselves. But the goodness of the New Testament isn’t as obvious upon examination, and it’s not entirely clear that it’s even better than the Old Testament. A respectable case can be mounted either way, but even if we decide that the New Testament is an improvement upon the old one, it’s still undeniably evil.

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Letter to a Christian Nation — Sam Harris [Amazon]

Christopher Hitchens on Vicarious Redemption [YouTube]

Nonstampcollector – Modern Christian vs. Jesus [YouTube]

Mere Christianity — C.S. Lewis [Amazon]


CA22 The Byproduct Theory of Religion: Why We Believe in Gods



If naturalism is true, why do so many people believe in god? What is it about human psychology that has made belief in god, in one form or another, the default position for the overwhelming majority of human beings that have ever lived? The theory of religion as a byproduct provides a potential answer. It’s possible that religious ideas are byproducts of normal human psychological modules that evolved for other reasons. Our psychological evolution imbued us with theory of mind, decoupled cognition, agency detection, and other useful functions for social animals. These modules interact and misfire — creating beliefs in souls, an afterlife, and even gods.

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

J. Anderson Thomson – American Atheists Lecture [YouTube]

Why We Believe in God(s) – J. Anderson Thomson [Amazon]

Steven Pinker on Byproduct Theory [YouTube]

Michael Shermer on Belief [YouTube]

Paul Bloom on Byproduct Theory [YouTube]

Paul Bloom on Dualism [Edge.org]

Why Would Anyone Believe in God? – Justin Barrett [Amazon]

The Believing Brain – Michael Shermer [Amazon]

Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought – Pascal Boyer [Amazon]


CA21 Divine Hiddenness



Why would God hide? If God wants us to know he exists, he’s not off to a great start. Being invisible, silent, and undetectable in every way isn’t exactly what one would expect from a god who wants you to know the truth. The Bible says, “Seek, and ye shall find,” but not everyone who honestly seeks becomes a Christian, or even a theist. How can this be if God wants us to know he exists, save us from hell, and have a relationship with us?

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Christopher Hitchens on Wishful Thinking [YouTube]

Christopher Hitchens vs. Alister McGrath [YouTube]

The Demon Haunted World [Amazon]

Theoretical BS on Divine Hiddenness [YouTube]


CA20 Pascal’s Wager



What if you’re wrong? Aren’t you afraid of going to hell? Many Christians claim that their belief is the safe bet — they have nothing to lose and everything to gain. We examine Pascal’s Wager and decide if one of the most popular arguments in favor of belief should make us lose as much sleep as Christians seem to think it should.

CA Patreon

Follow CA on Facebook

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Pascal’s Wager [wiki]

Tracie Harris on The Scathing Atheist [YouTube]

Matt Dillahunty on Pascal [YouTube]

Christopher Hitchens on Pascal [YouTube]


CA19 The Euthyphro Dilemma



Are good actions commanded by God because they are good? Or are good actions good because God commands them? We discuss Euthyphro’s Dilemma, the apologists’ favored “third horn” solution, and revisit the Problem of Holiness.

CA Patreon

Follow us on Facebook and Twitter

Contact: emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes; it’s objectively moral.

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Euthyphro Dilemma [wiki]

William Lane Craig on Euthyphro [YouTube]

Apologist Matt Slick on Euthyphro [CARM]

TMM on Euthyphro [YouTube]

Hank Green on Divine Command Theory and Meta-Ethics [YouTube]


CA18 Moral Luck and Responsibility (Free Will pt. II)



If humans have no free will, can we assign praise or blame? Is it reasonable to condemn someone as immoral in a deterministic universe? We explore the concept of moral responsibility in a naturalistic world and distinguish between causal and moral responsibility. We also examine the problem of moral luck, which makes a case for determinism and against moral responsibility.

CA Facebook

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes or Facebook, pretty please.

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Moral Luck by Thomas Nagel [PDF]

Compatibilism: Crash Course Philosophy [YouTube]

William Lane Craig on Moral Responsibility [YouTube]

Tumors and Behavior [The Atlantic]


CA17 Free Will and Determinism (pt. I)



Do we really have free will, or are we determined to think and behave as we do? Most Christian worldviews take it on as an assumption, but their conception of free will can’t be justified.

CA Facebook

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes or Facebook (you have no choice).

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Hank Green on Determinism [YouTube]

Free Will by Sam Harris [Amazon]

Sam Harris on Free Will [YouTube]

The Gene by Siddhartha Mukherjee [Amazon]

Dan Harris and Sam Harris on Introspection [10% Happier Podcast]

Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart [PDF]

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy


CA16 Is Religion Child Abuse?



There seems to be genuine disagreement within the atheist community over religion and child abuse. We’ll explore the nuances and examine the instances where religion appears to be responsible for child abuse. We’ll also discuss whether the intellectual roots of religious child abuse can be traced back to the Bible and justified therein.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Atheist Experience on Religion as Child Abuse [YouTube]

Richard Dawkins in a Hell House [YouTube]

Richard Dawkins on Religious Child Abuse [YouTube]

Spare the Rod Article [NYT]

Child Beating Article [HuffPost]

Child Deaths Caused By Medical Denial [MassKids]

Laci Green Sex Ed [YouTube]

Abstinence-Only Sex Ed [Article]

Hitchens on Circumcision [YouTube]

WHO on Circumcision [Article]

Religious Exemptions for Abuse [Pew]


CA15 Faith



We discuss whether faith is a reliable foundation for belief. When arguments fail, believers often say that we just need to have faith. But is faith a valid way of knowing something?

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Matt Dillahunty on Faith

Steven Pinker on Epistemology

Richard Dawkins on Science

Jerry Coyne on Faith

“Living by Faith” (Hymn)


CA14 Creationism’s Greatest Hits — Defending Evolution



We address 20 common objections to evolution, give some evidence supporting the theory, and try to figure out why some Christians have a problem with evolution in the first place.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Objections (in chronological order)

  1. Evolution is just a theory
  2. Why are there still monkeys?
  3. Why don’t chimpanzees give birth to humans?
  4. You weren’t there!
  5. Microevolution / Macroevolution
  6. Evolution has never been observed
  7. Evolution is unfalsifiable
  8. Genetics conflicts with evolution
  9. Mutations are always harmful
  10. Random chance couldn’t make an organism
  11. 2nd Law of Thermodynamics
  12. The Cambrian Explosion
  13. Missing Links
  14. Carbon Dating
  15. Irreducible Complexity
  16. Bacterial Flagellum
  17. Abiogenesis
  18. DNA is a language
  19. Teach the controversy!
  20. Evolution leads to immorality

Science in the Soul and The Greatest Show on Earth by Richard Dawkins [Amazon]

Finding Darwin’s God by Kenneth Miller [Amazon]

Richard Dawkins with a creationist [YouTube]

Scientific American on Creationism

Michael Russell on Abiogenesis

Popular Science on Abiogenesis

Most Recent Creationist Data on America from Gallup (2017)

TalkOrigins

Evolution FAQ

RationalWiki


CA13 Prayer Studies



Nothing fails like prayer! We examine prayer studies, try to figure out how prayer is supposed to work, and wonder why God is so shy now that everyone has video cameras in their pockets.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Sean Carroll: From Particles to People


CA12 Argument From Miracles



Believers often point to miracle claims as validations of their religious beliefs. This argument is the basis for other popular apologetics regarding the resurrection of Jesus, the power of prayer, and famous anecdotes of miraculous events, so let’s examine the bare bones of the argument from miracles.

Thank you to everyone who’s been leaving reviews on Facebook and iTunes, I’ve been stunned at the kindness of all of you!

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Rationality Rules on Miracles


The Satanic Panic – CA Halloween Special



Get your pentagrams ready, because today we’re talking about the Satanic Panic, recovered memory, and the spirited debate in the Christian community over whether Jesus approves of Halloween.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

8bit Theme Music for this episode

Elizabeth Loftus on False Memory

Remembering Satan by Lawrence Wright

The Demon-Haunted World by Carl Sagan (pgs. 136-168) was a huge resource for this episode.


CA11 Satan



We discuss the Christian concept of Satan and wonder why he exists in the first place. Why would God make a perfect plan and then create someone whose primary purpose is ruining it? His ways are indeed inscrutable.

Hail Satan!

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Noah Lugeons interviews Chris Matheson

The Scathing Atheist

The Story of God by Chris Matheson

Atheist Experience

Barna Poll on Satan

Christian Apologist on Satan

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Hail Satan!


CA10 The Old Testament Doesn’t Count



Christians expend significant energy trying to distance themselves from the horrors of the Old Testament. Apologists often try to justify their diminishing or dismissing of the Old Testament’s authority by employing Covenant theology. We explore that idea along with other common arguments Christians use to ignore the bad parts of the Old Testament.

Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Matt Dillahunty on the Old Testament


CA09 Darwinism, Eugenics, and Hitler



Does atheism inevitably lead to social Darwinism? Are atheists implicated in Nazi eugenics? We continue our discussion from last week’s episode into the territory of Darwinism, eugenics, Hitler, and whether atheists are able to morally condemn the events of the 20th century.

[Part II of II]

Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA08 Atheism and 20th Century Atrocities



Hitler! Stalin! Mao! Any lengthy debate with a Christian apologist seems to lead to those names. The idea, either stated explicitly or implicitly, is that atheism inevitably leads to war, genocide, and the crumbling of society. So were the bloody atrocities of the 20th century the logical result of the spread of atheism? Many Christian apologists seem to think that the death of God lead to the cruelties of the last century, but this idea doesn’t hold up to the slightest bit of scrutiny.

[Part I of II]

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA07 Mother Teresa



Mother Teresa’s work greatly increased the amount of poverty and suffering in the world and her reputation deserves to be exposed for what it is: a myth. She was not, by her own admission, a humanitarian who worked to alleviate poverty. She thought suffering was good for people and had no interest in alleviating poverty — pain brings one closer to Jesus. She worked tirelessly to impose misogynistic laws banning divorce, contraceptives, and abortions everywhere she could. She had warm relations with genocidal maniacs like the Duvalier family in Haiti, she took money stolen from the elderly and didn’t return it, she sold modern versions of indulgences, and she took donations meant to help the poor and used it to build convents instead.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA06 Problem of Holiness



What does it mean when we say that God is holy or morally good? Does it mean anything at all? We take a look at Jeremy Beahan’s Problem of Holiness and consider the possibility that God’s goodness may actually be meaningless.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Jeremy Beahan on the Problem of Holiness


CA05 Biblical Prophecies



Many believers argue that Biblical prophecies have been fulfilled and that this needs to be accounted for. But how persuasive are these Biblical prophecies? And what would a prophecy look like if it was made by God? We take a look at the celebrated Ezekiel 26 prophecy, as well as prophecies regarding Jesus.

I also want to thank Noah Lugeons of the Scathing Atheist for giving me a shout out on their show, which lead to an influx of new listeners to Counter Apologetics. Hi new listeners! Unfortunately, I’m recording ahead of schedule and I won’t be able to give a proper thanks until next week. Until then, please support the incredible multipodcasting efforts of Noah, Heath, Eli, and Lucinda. They’re amazing.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA04 Hell



According to Pew data, 82% of America’s Evangelicals believe in Hell. However, the traditional conception of Hell falls apart under any amount of scrutiny and reveals the haphazard, man-made nature of the idea.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA03 Problem of Evil



The Problem of Evil! I discuss the most common defense, free will. Also, is heaven is full of lobotomized robots? I also discuss hell, animal suffering, eye burrowing insects, and why the logical POE maybe isn’t so bad after all.

CA Facebook and Twitter

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA02 Abortion and the Afterlife



Do aborted fetuses go to heaven? If the answer is yes, then abortion might be the only guaranteed path to Heaven. Since the way to Heaven is straight and narrow and most won’t make it, abortion may not be the evil that many Christians believe it is. If you take Christianity seriously, isn’t abortion the most loving decision you could make for the child?

CA Facebook

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers


CA01 The Fine-Tuning Argument



The Fine Tuning Argument is considered by many to be the best argument apologists have on offer. So in the spirit of attacking theism at its best, here are a few reasons I don’t accept the Fine-Tuning Argument presented by the religious.

CA Facebook 

CA Patreon

emersongreen@protonmail.com

Emerson’s Blog

Rate the show on iTunes!

Magic Tricks by Whalers

Sean Carroll Debate

The Big Picture