We discuss several reasons to doubt skeptical theism, including Paul Draper’s objection, phenomenal conservatism, divine silence during tragedies, Pandora’s box, and moral paralysis.
Transcripts available at emersongreenblog.wordpress.com
Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook
Additional music by ichika Nito and was used with permission.
Follow me on Twitter @waldenpod
/ / /
Ryan Stringer – Evil and Skeptical Theism (2012) [infidels.org]
Aron Lucas – The Argument from Cognitive Biases (2018) [infidels.org]
Schopenhauer on the Sea Turtles [Goodreads]
Skeptical Theism [SEP]
/ / /
S = some facts about suffering
I = the hypothesis of indifference
T = the hypothesis of theism
(1) Pr(S/I) = quite high
(2) Pr(S/T) = quite low
(3) Therefore, Pr(S/I) > Pr(S/T)
(4) Therefore, S is evidence is that favors indifference over theism
/ / /
00:00-03:32 Evidential arguments from evil
03:33-06:38 The theological premise
06:39-08:59 Skeptical theism
09:00-13:32 Concrete examples of gratuitous suffering
13:33-15:31 Draper’s objection
15:32-17:28 Phenomenal conservatism
17:29-21:02 Moral unintelligibility
21:03-22:59 Divine silence during tragedies
23:00-30:25 Pandora’s box, reliable cognitive faculties, & moral paralysis
30:26-36:12 Conclusion
Podcast: Play in new window | Download